No alternative use enforceable payment right

No alternative use enforceable payment right for work to date is the last phase in the satisfaction of performance obligations in IFRS 15 Revenue recognition. This is part of a primary and fundamental subject in the recognition of revenue. There are two ways of recognising revenue, revenue recognition over time and revenue recognition at a point in time. Revenue recognition over time is often referred to as the ‘Percentage of completion‘ method under the (superseded) IAS 11 Construction contracts.

Revenue recognition at a point in time

The general principle is the revenue is recognised at a point in time (and as such it is the most common type of sales transaction at least in volume, just think of: a retailer sells a candy bar for cash in the shopping mall). As a result there are three criterion (see below ability, direct the use and obtain benefits from) that have to be met to qualify as revenue recognised over time.

Revenue recognition

Under IFRS 15, an entity only recognises revenue when it satisfies an identified performance obligation by transferring a promised good or service to a customer. A good or service is considered to be transferred when the customer obtains control.

Obtain control

IFRS 15 states that “control of an asset refers to the ability to direct the use and obtain substantially all of the remaining benefits from the asset”. [IFRS 15 33] No alternative use enforceable payment right

The IASB explained the key terms in the definition of control in the Basis for Conclusions, as follows: [IFRS 15 BC 118]

Ability –

a customer must have the present right to direct the use of, and obtain substantially all of the remaining benefits from, an asset for an entity to recognise revenue. For example, in a contract that requires a manufacturer to produce an asset for a customer, it might be clear that the customer will ultimately have the right to direct the use of, and obtain substantially all of the remaining benefits from, the asset. However, the entity should not recognise revenue until the customer has actually obtained that right (which, depending on the contract, may occur during production or afterwards). No alternative use enforceable payment right

Direct the use of –

a customer’s ability to direct the use of an asset refers to the customer’s right to deploy or to allow another entity to deploy that asset in its activities or to restrict another entity from deploying that asset. No alternative use enforceable payment right

Obtain the benefits from –

the customer must have the ability to obtain substantially all of the remaining benefits from an asset for the customer to obtain control of it. No alternative use enforceable payment right Conceptually, the benefits from a good or service are potential cash flows (either an increase in cash inflows or a decrease in cash outflows). IFRS 15 33 indicates that a customer can obtain the benefits directly or indirectly in many ways, such as: using the asset to produce goods or services (including public services); using the asset to enhance the value of other assets; using the asset to settle a liability or reduce an expense; selling or exchanging the asset; pledging the asset to secure a loan; or holding the asset.

Transfer of control

Under IFRS 15, the transfer of control to the customer represents the transfer of the rights with regard to the good or service. The customer’s ability to receive the benefit from the good or service is represented by its right to substantially all of the cash inflows, or the reduction of the cash outflows, generated by the goods or services. Upon transfer of control, the customer has sole possession of the right to use the good or service for the remainder of its economic life or to consume the good or service in its own operations. No alternative use AND enforceable right to payment work to 

Performance obligation satisfied over time/ Performance obligation satisfied at a point in time

Frequently, entities transfer the promised goods or services to the customer over time. While the determination of whether goods or services are transferred over time is straightforward in some contracts (e.g., many service contracts), it is more difficult in other contracts.

IFRS 15 35 states that an entity transfers control of a good or service over time if one of the following criteria is met:

  • As the entity performs, the customer simultaneously receives and consumes the benefits provided by the entity’s performance.
  • The entity’s performance creates or enhances an asset (e.g., work in progress) that the customer controls as the asset is created or enhanced. No alternative use enforceable payment right
  • The entity’s performance does not create an asset with an alternative use to the entity and the entity has an enforceable right to payment for performance completed to date.  No alternative use enforceable payment right

The question

The following decision tree illustrates how to evaluate whether control transfers over time/at a point in time:


The third question (see below explanation) is: Does the entity’s performance create an asset with no alternative use to the entity AND the entity has enforceable right to payment for performance completed to date?

Yes  |  No

Reference – IFRS 15 36IFRS 15 B6 – B8IFRS 15 37IFRS 15 B9 – B12


Document your decisions in your financial close file to facilitate internal review and approval and external audits.

Asset with no alternative use and right to payment 

In some cases, it may be unclear whether the asset that an entity creates or enhances is controlled by the customer when considering the first two criteria for evaluating whether control transfers over time. Therefore, the Board added a third criterion, which requires revenue to be recognised over time if both of the following two requirements are met: No alternative use enforceable payment right

1. Asset with alternative use

The entity’s performance does not create an asset with alternative use to the entity. When the entity’s performance creates an asset with an alternative use to the entity (e.g., standard inventory items), the entity can readily direct the asset to another customer. In those cases, the entity (not the customer) controls the asset as it is created because the customer does not have the ability to direct the use of the asset or restrict the entity from directing that asset to another customer. The standard includes the requirements for ’alternative use’ in IFRS 15 36IFRS 15 B6 – B8. No alternative use is illustrated in Example 15 in IFRS 15 IE73 – IE76.

2. Enforceable right to payment for performance completed to date

The entity has an enforceable right to payment for performance completed to date (see example 16 IFRS 15 IE77 – IE80). To evaluate this criterion, the entity is required to consider the terms of the contract and any laws or regulations that relate to it. IFRS 15 states that the right to payment for performance completed to date need not be for a fixed amount. However, at any time during the contract term, an entity must be entitled to an amount that at least compensates the entity for performance completed to date (IFRS 15 B9 – B12), even if the contract is terminated by the customer (or another party) for reasons other than the entity’s failure to perform as promised [IFRS 15 37] The IASB concluded that a customer’s obligation to pay for the entity’s performance is an indicator that the customer has obtained benefit from the entity’s performance. [IFRS 15 BC142] No alternative use enforceable payment right

See also: The IFRS Foundation

No alternative use enforceable payment right

No alternative use enforceable payment right No alternative use enforceable payment right  No alternative use enforceable payment right 

No alternative use enforceable payment right  No alternative use enforceable payment right  No alternative use enforceable payment right 

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *